A pair of red clay boxing gloves hanging by their laces

Sales objections and how to counter them in practice

20 objections our AI owners throw, with a counter to practice, the low blow to avoid, and the sales method each counter comes from. Pick one and spar the owner who throws it. Every owner is an AI character (how they work), standing in for real trades counted in the weigh-in.

20 objections

“Let me think about it.”

Thrown by Gus, roofer (AI character)

What it usually means here: You have not given him anything worth thinking about yet, or he feels pushed.

Counter: “Fair enough. What part would you be thinking over?”

Low blow: Inventing a deadline so he has to decide today.

A “what” question asks him to name the real snag instead of hiding behind the stall. Method: Never Split the Difference, Chris Voss with Tahl Raz (2016).

Spar Gus

“Marketing is a scam. I get five of these calls a day.”

Thrown by Vic, hvac owner (AI character)

What it usually means here: He has been promised things before and got nothing. He is testing whether you crack.

Counter: “Sounds like you’ve been promised the moon more than once. What did the last one promise you?”

Low blow: Defending your industry, or promising results.

Naming the feeling takes the heat out; the question gets him telling his story. Method: Never Split the Difference, Chris Voss with Tahl Raz (2016).

Spar Vic

“I’m good. Word of mouth keeps me busy.”

Thrown by Benny, handyman (AI character)

What it usually means here: He is proud and mostly right. The gap is in the months word of mouth goes quiet.

Counter: “That’s a great spot to be in. What does the calendar look like in your slowest months?”

Low blow: Telling him word of mouth is not enough.

A problem question about timing lets him find the slow season himself. Method: SPIN Selling, Neil Rackham (1988).

Spar Benny

“Well, it was nice meeting you. Do you have a card?”

Thrown by Joanne, insurance agent (AI character)

What it usually means here: Your answer to “what do you do” was too vague to picture anyone to send you.

Counter: “I help roofers and HVAC owners get more calls from their own town. Who’s the best contractor client you have?”

Low blow: Handing over a card and walking away, or listing every service you sell.

A narrow, specific answer gives her someone to picture, then the question turns to her world. Method: This Is Marketing, Seth Godin (2018).

Spar Joanne

“Yeah, I’ll keep you in mind if anything comes up.”

Thrown by Phil, realtor (AI character)

What it usually means here: He cannot describe you in one sentence, or he has not seen proof yet.

Counter: “Appreciate that. Who’s the last person who asked you for a contractor recommendation?”

Low blow: Asking for referrals in general, with no name or moment attached.

Asking about his last real moment makes the referral concrete without asking for a favor. Method: How to Win Friends and Influence People, Dale Carnegie (1936).

Spar Phil

“I’ll definitely mention you if it comes up.”

Thrown by Lorraine, painting company owner (AI character)

What it usually means here: She wants to help and will forget. It has to be easy.

Counter: “Thank you. Would it help if I wrote a two-line text you could just forward?”

Low blow: Leaving it on her to remember.

A small, easy first yes makes the bigger one natural. Method: Influence, Robert Cialdini (1984).

Spar Lorraine

“I don’t know. That’s a big jump.”

Thrown by Dewey, plumbing company owner (AI character)

What it usually means here: He does not see what the money buys, or the timing is wrong.

Counter: “You’re probably thinking I’m squeezing you after a good year. Can I show you what changed, and then you tell me if it’s fair?”

Low blow: Apologizing for the price, or dropping it on the spot.

Saying his worst thought first (an accusation audit) takes away its sting. Method: Never Split the Difference, Chris Voss with Tahl Raz (2016).

Spar Dewey

“Honestly, I’m thinking about canceling.”

Thrown by Marisol, landscaping company owner (AI character)

What it usually means here: She is hurt more than she is leaving. She found the mistake herself.

Counter: “That’s on me, and I’m sorry. It sounds like the worst part is you found it before I did.”

Low blow: Blaming a tool, an employee or the platform.

Owning it with no excuse is the only thing that lowers the temperature. Method: Extreme Ownership, Jocko Willink and Leif Babin (2015).

Spar Marisol

“Well, we should get started soon. Nice chatting!”

Thrown by Bev, cpa (AI character)

What it usually means here: You talked about yourself. She never got to tell you who she sees struggling.

Counter: “Before you go, who are your clients who had the roughest year?”

Low blow: One more round of your pitch on the way out.

People remember the conversations where they did the talking. Method: How to Win Friends and Influence People, Dale Carnegie (1936).

Spar Bev

“Leave me a card, I’ll take a look.”

Thrown by Ray, auto detailer (AI character)

What it usually means here: A customer is waiting and you have not earned the next minute.

Counter: “Will do. Is it a bad time to ask one quick question before I go?”

Low blow: Talking faster to get the pitch in.

A no-oriented question lets him say “no, go ahead” and feel in control. Method: Never Split the Difference, Chris Voss with Tahl Raz (2016).

Spar Ray

“We’re doing okay, honestly. Maybe another time.”

Thrown by Colette, flooring showroom owner (AI character)

What it usually means here: She does not want to be sold to in her own store.

Counter: “Glad to hear it. If you could change one thing about how people find you, what would it be?”

Low blow: Pointing out what is wrong with her website.

She names the problem in her own words, so she owns it. Method: SPIN Selling, Neil Rackham (1988).

Spar Colette

“Send me the proposal and I’ll look it over.”

Thrown by Donna, pest control owner (AI character)

What it usually means here: Someone else decides, or she is not convinced.

Counter: “Happy to. Besides you, who else weighs in on a decision like this?”

Low blow: Emailing a proposal and waiting.

It surfaces the second decision maker before the proposal dies in an inbox. Method: SPIN Selling, Neil Rackham (1988).

Spar Donna

“Yeah, that’s what the last guy said.”

Thrown by Earl, concrete contractor (AI character)

What it usually means here: Your promises sound like the people who burned him.

Counter: “Fair. What did the last guy say that didn’t happen?”

Low blow: Promising you are different.

His answer tells you exactly what not to promise and what he needs to see. Method: Never Split the Difference, Chris Voss with Tahl Raz (2016).

Spar Earl

“Come on, you can’t just do some posts for me?”

Thrown by Tyler, online t-shirt brand (AI character)

What it usually means here: He is not a fit and needs a clear answer, not a maybe.

Counter: “I’m not the right fit: I only help local service businesses. Here’s where I’d start with three hundred a month instead.”

Low blow: A vague “maybe later” that wastes both your time.

A clear, kind no with a pointer keeps your reputation and his goodwill. Method: Essentialism, Greg McKeown (2014).

Spar Tyler

“How much does it cost?”

Thrown by Earl, concrete contractor (AI character)

What it usually means here: A fair question, asked before he has told you what is broken.

Counter: “Fair question. It depends on what’s broken. Can I ask two questions so I give you a real number?”

Low blow: Quoting a package price in the first minute.

A price with no problem attached is just a cost. Method: SPIN Selling, Neil Rackham (1988).

Spar Earl

“I don’t have time right now.”

Thrown by Vic, hvac owner (AI character)

What it usually means here: He might be busy. He might be testing you.

Counter: “Is now a bad time? I can call back. Tomorrow at 7:30 or Thursday after lunch?”

Low blow: “This will only take a minute” and then ten minutes.

Giving him the easy no, then two specific times, respects the clock. Method: Never Split the Difference, Chris Voss with Tahl Raz (2016).

Spar Vic

“I’d have to talk to my wife.”

Thrown by Colette, flooring showroom owner (AI character)

What it usually means here: A steady style needs time and a partner’s okay. It is rarely a no.

Counter: “Makes sense. What do you think she’d ask first?”

Low blow: Pushing for a yes before the talk at home.

It shows respect for how she decides and gets the real questions out now. Method: Crucial Conversations, Kerry Patterson, Joseph Grenny, Ron McMillan, Al Switzler (2002).

Spar Colette

“We already have someone for that.”

Thrown by Dewey, plumbing company owner (AI character)

What it usually means here: Loyalty, or inertia. Either way, do not attack the other person.

Counter: “Good. What do you like most about what they do? Anything you wish they did?”

Low blow: Knocking the other company.

Asking what he likes earns trust; the wish list shows the gap. Method: How to Win Friends and Influence People, Dale Carnegie (1936).

Spar Dewey

“We tried that before and it didn’t work.”

Thrown by Gus, roofer (AI character)

What it usually means here: He paid for something that failed, and he is still sore about it.

Counter: “Didn’t work?”

Low blow: Explaining why your version would work.

A mirror, repeating his last words as a question, makes him tell you what happened. Method: Never Split the Difference, Chris Voss with Tahl Raz (2016).

Spar Gus

“Just email me something.”

Thrown by Donna, pest control owner (AI character)

What it usually means here: A polite exit. Email is where calls go to die.

Counter: “Sure. So I send the right thing, what would you look for in it?”

Low blow: Sending the whole brochure.

It turns the brush-off into a question about what matters to her. Method: SPIN Selling, Neil Rackham (1988).

Spar Donna

Where the counters come from

The counters are ours, written in plain words. Each one leans on a published sales or negotiation method. We name the source; we don’t quote it.

  • Never Split the Difference, Chris Voss with Tahl Raz (2016). Mirroring, labeling, calibrated questions, no-oriented questions.
  • SPIN Selling, Neil Rackham (1988). Research by Huthwaite across thousands of sales calls; problem and implication questions.
  • This Is Marketing, Seth Godin (2018). The smallest viable audience; who it’s for.
  • How to Win Friends and Influence People, Dale Carnegie (1936). Talk in terms of the other person’s interests.
  • Influence, Robert Cialdini (1984). Small commitments, reciprocity, social proof used honestly.
  • Extreme Ownership, Jocko Willink and Leif Babin (2015). Own the mistake with no excuses.
  • Essentialism, Greg McKeown (2014). Saying no gracefully.
  • Crucial Conversations, Kerry Patterson, Joseph Grenny, Ron McMillan, Al Switzler (2002). Make it safe; facts before the story.

These are the objections in this gym, not a ranking of how often real owners say them. Want reps on one skill? Try the drills, or read how the judges score.